Where the theory comes from
CHC theory joins two lines of research. In the 1940s Raymond Cattell proposed that general intelligence splits into fluid intelligence (Gf), reasoning with new problems, and crystallized intelligence (Gc), knowledge and skills built up through education and experience. His student John Horn expanded this over several decades to around nine broad abilities.
In 1993 John Carroll published Human Cognitive Abilities, a reanalysis of more than 460 data sets collected over most of the 20th century. He found a three-level structure with a general factor at the top, broad abilities in the middle and narrow abilities at the bottom, which matched Horn's broad abilities closely. In the late 1990s Kevin McGrew and colleagues merged the two into one taxonomy, and the name Cattell-Horn-Carroll stuck. It has been revised several times since, including a major update by Schneider and McGrew in 2018.
The three strata
- Stratum III: general intelligence (g). The shared factor that explains why people who do well on one kind of task tend to do well on others. Carroll included it; Horn doubted it, and the CHC model leaves room for both views.
- Stratum II: broad abilities. About ten to sixteen broad abilities, depending on the version. These are what test publishers usually report as index scores.
- Stratum I: narrow abilities. More than 80 specific skills, such as induction, lexical knowledge, memory span or perceptual speed. A single subtest usually measures one or two of these.
The practical point of the hierarchy is that an overall IQ and a profile answer different questions. The overall score, which mostly reflects g, is the best single predictor of learning and job performance. The broad-ability profile shows how someone gets there: two adults with an IQ of 105 may differ by 20 points or more in working memory or processing speed, and that difference can matter for study, work or a clinical question.
The broad abilities that matter most
- Fluid reasoning (Gf): solving unfamiliar problems by finding rules, as in matrices and number series. See fluid vs crystallized intelligence.
- Comprehension-knowledge (Gc): vocabulary, general knowledge and verbal understanding.
- Quantitative knowledge (Gq): mathematical knowledge and reasoning with numbers.
- Reading and writing (Grw): literacy skills.
- Working memory capacity (Gwm): holding and manipulating information over a few seconds, such as repeating digits backward.
- Learning efficiency (Gl) and retrieval fluency (Gr): storing new information and calling it up quickly. Earlier versions combined these as long-term storage and retrieval (Glr).
- Visual processing (Gv): imagining, rotating and analyzing shapes and spatial patterns.
- Auditory processing (Ga): analyzing speech sounds and other auditory patterns.
- Processing speed (Gs): doing simple tasks quickly and accurately.
- Reaction and decision speed (Gt): speed of very simple decisions.
Further abilities, such as domain-specific knowledge and several sensory and motor abilities, appear in the full model but are rarely tested in intelligence batteries.
How modern IQ tests use CHC
The Woodcock-Johnson III, published in 2001, was the first major battery designed directly on the CHC model, and its successors still are. Other batteries map their index scores onto it. The Stanford-Binet Fifth Edition reports five factors (fluid reasoning, knowledge, quantitative reasoning, visual-spatial processing and working memory) that correspond to CHC broad abilities. Wechsler indices line up in a similar way: verbal comprehension with Gc, fluid reasoning with Gf, visual-spatial with Gv, working memory with Gwm and processing speed with Gs.
CHC also gave psychologists a shared language. In cross-battery assessment, a practitioner can combine subtests from different publishers to cover the abilities that matter for a particular question, such as a suspected learning difficulty.
The model has critics. Some researchers argue that once g is accounted for, many broad abilities add little prediction, and the number of broad abilities keeps changing between versions. It remains, however, the common framework for test construction.
Our CHC-style test
Our CHC-style cognitive test is modeled on that structure. It samples up to six broad abilities (fluid reasoning, comprehension-knowledge, visual processing, working memory, learning efficiency and processing speed), with two tasks per ability in the Full version, and the longer versions report a profile alongside the overall score. It is an online estimate, not a clinical assessment; for how it is built and normed, see our methodology.
Sources
Carroll, J. B. Human Cognitive Abilities: A Survey of Factor-Analytic Studies. Cambridge University Press, 1993.
Cattell, R. B. "Theory of fluid and crystallized intelligence: a critical experiment". Journal of Educational Psychology, 1963.
Horn, J. L. and Cattell, R. B. "Refinement and test of the theory of fluid and crystallized general intelligences". Journal of Educational Psychology, 1966.
McGrew, K. S. "CHC theory and the human cognitive abilities project". Intelligence, 2009.
Schneider, W. J. and McGrew, K. S. "The Cattell-Horn-Carroll theory of cognitive abilities". In Contemporary Intellectual Assessment, 4th edition. Guilford Press, 2018.
Flanagan, D. P., Ortiz, S. O. and Alfonso, V. C. Essentials of Cross-Battery Assessment, 3rd edition. Wiley, 2013.
Frequently asked questions
What is CHC theory?
CHC theory is a model of intelligence with three levels: general intelligence (g), around ten broad abilities such as fluid reasoning and processing speed, and many narrow skills. It is the main framework used to build and interpret modern IQ tests.
Who were Cattell, Horn and Carroll?
The name combines Raymond Cattell and John Horn, who developed the fluid and crystallized intelligence theory, and John Carroll, whose 1993 reanalysis of more than 460 data sets produced the three-stratum model. Their work was merged into one taxonomy in the late 1990s.
How does CHC theory describe intelligence?
It treats intelligence as a hierarchy rather than a single number. Your overall IQ reflects g, but two people with the same IQ can have very different profiles across broad abilities such as verbal knowledge, working memory and speed.
What is the CHC model used for?
Test publishers use the CHC model to decide which abilities each subtest should measure. The model itself is a taxonomy: a list of defined broad and narrow abilities with codes such as Gf, Gc, Gwm and Gs.
Has CHC theory changed over time?
Yes. Its major 2018 revision by Schneider and McGrew, among other changes, split long-term storage and retrieval into learning efficiency and retrieval fluency.
What are the broad abilities in CHC theory?
The ones most tests measure are fluid reasoning, comprehension-knowledge, quantitative knowledge, reading and writing, working memory, learning efficiency, retrieval fluency, visual processing, auditory processing and processing speed.